Open questions
What the records have not yet answered, and where to look next. A search that came back empty is not proof that something didn’t happen; it only tells us where not to look again.
Weak or unproven leads, like the 1888 Sollender family and other people of our names, are on the Leads & long shots page.
Both sides Open since 23 October
- Max’s ship, and his marriage. Max’s S.S. India is now found: it landed on 16 August 1883, not in 1877 as he swore (probably him: “M. Salender”, 26). Still open: Moritz’s ship (1882/83), Abraham’s (his card says 14 May 1886; nothing in the index) (Sarah and Joseph’s crossing is now probably found: the S.S. Suevia, 1 August 1884), where Max married Sarah Unger (about 1878, probably in Galicia; her family were the Ungers of Biecz, near Gorlice, probably), whether any sisters came, what became of their parents Josef and Basche (no death or arrival in New York, and none in the Tarnów books; probably Ryglice, whose books are not online), Moritz’s naturalization (about 1887–89; not in the online indexes under any spelling tried; Max’s and Abraham’s 1894 ones are now found), where Max went in 1894, what became of Sarah’s father Salomon Unger (alive in 1885) and her mother Feige (alive in 1862; her death is not in the indexed Biecz books), and whether her brothers Schobse and Leib lived (Philip Unger, the 1921 witness, was her half-brother, probably; his 1896 ship is now found), and whether the Joseph Fischer who witnessed Anna’s 1907 wedding is Benjamin’s father-in-law. Open More
- How was our Samuel Leder related to Mendel? A younger Samuel Leder (b. Tarnów 1875, d. 1950) and Rose Reimer were probably Mendel and Sara Dacha’s children. Our Samuel (1867–1930) was close kin to them (probable): an uncle, cousin or half-brother. His 1930 certificate’s parents and age may belong to the younger man, so “son of Mendel” is a guess. Whether Mendel was Basche Leder’s brother, making Samuel Abraham’s first cousin, is also a guess. Next: Basche’s own records, Dawid Leder of Ryglice, and the 1905 census page for Samuel, Fanny and Katy Leder. Guess More
- Who was the 1899 Samuel Leder of Ryglice? 36, widowed, going to his brother-in-law Laszkowitz at 92 Walton St, Brooklyn. Was he the Samuel (45) with Fanny and Katy Leder in the 1905 census? Open
- Samuel Leder’s headstone at Mount Hebron (plot 36-4-C-9-4L). Its Hebrew inscription should give his father’s Hebrew name, which would settle Mendel. No photo or transcription has been found online yet. Open
- Sara Dacha Leder’s maiden name: Gelb or Landau? Samuel’s 1930 death certificate (and a 1936 Social Security entry for a younger Samuel Leder) say Gelb; Rose Reimer’s 1936 death certificate says Landau. Open
- Lew’s birth certificate is not in New York’s digitized 1902 birth index. Next: the undigitized 1902 registers, and his 1942 draft card. Open
- Who was Yosef Solender’s father? Chane Leder née Solender was the daughter of Hersh and Perl Solender of Ryglice. If Yosef was her brother, Hersh was his father too. Next: the birth records of Chane’s sons Józef (about 1873) and Mojżesz (about 1879), which may name her parents again, and other Ryglice-area books. Round 3 found a Hersch Salender of Tarnów (died 1859, aged 60) with children Mordche 1838 and Jacob 1840, and a Markus Solender, melamed of Ryglice, but no Yosef in the Tarnów index. Rzepiennik’s books are not online anywhere, so the next step is a letter to the Rzepiennik Strzyżewski records office or the National Archive in Kraków; also Markus Solender’s death record. Guess
- The rov of Roś between 1880 and 1920, and the rov of Rzepiennik. Known so far for Roś: R’ Yisrael Isser Spektor (early 1800s) and Szmuel Łuniew (1840). Next: the Einhorn yizkor book (Yiddish vol. 1) and the Russian lists of crown rabbis for Grodno province. Open
- Isaac Yellen’s ship: found. SS Cymric, Liverpool to Boston, 21 February 1905. More Still open: Bertha’s ship with Lena and Mary (probably later in 1905; the 1906 Baltimore “Breine Gelin” does not fit), and the name of Isaac’s brother, already in Chicago on W. Harrison St in 1905; his first name on the list is hard to read. Open
- Jacob Keller’s 1949 death certificate, which would prove the “Yaakov Moshe bar Tzvi Aryeh” stone in Paramus is his. Open
- Ida Keller’s obituary (Rutland, 1980). Open
- The Golomb–Kellar lead: Eliyahu Golomb, founder of the Haganah, was born in Wołkowysk in 1893 and his mother was Esther née Kellar. Any link to our Kellers is a pure guess. Guess
Father’s side Which ship brought Abraham?
His own papers say the Moravia in 1887 (Hamburg 20 May → New York 20 June 1887), but no Moravia list has him: every Moravia arrival in New York from July 1887 to July 1888 was read page by page. A possible match is The Queen, Liverpool → New York, 6 June 1888: “Abm Solinder”, 24, laborer, after leaving Hamburg on 18 May 1888 for Grimsby and Liverpool by the Hamburg index. His own petition also says he left Hamburg about 20 May, one year off. Possiblerecordindexrecord The whole case
Evidence against The Queen: The family tradition, from Dr. James Salander, is that Abraham “came two years before the big snow” and made money shoveling snow. The big snow was the Great Blizzard of 1888, which hit New York on 11–14 March 1888. If the story is right, he arrived around 1886, and in any case before March 1888. That fits the 1884 and 1887 records, but not The Queen, which landed three months after the blizzard. The Hamburg entry of 18 May 1888 could be a different Abraham Solender. family
Ruled out, 22–23 Oct: his 1910 Declaration of Intention gives the same Moravia answer as his petition. record Five earlier Moravia lists were read line by line, and he is on none of them: 18 May 1886 (Hamburg), 17 July 1886 (Stettin), 22 December 1886, 3 February 1887 and 16 March 1887 (Hamburg & Havre). record A “Chaim Soll” on the SS Gellert, 24 July 1886, was 19 and from Minsk. record The Hamburg index for 1880–92 has no Abraham Solender before 18 May 1888. index Two other Sollenders of 1886, Joseph and Hersch, are on the Leads page.
Where to look next: his entry on the Hamburg indirect-emigration list, 18 May 1888 (volume 74, May–June 1888), which gives his home town. It is locked online: FamilySearch shows the film only at a FamilySearch library or center, and Ancestry’s page needs a subscription or trial. If it says Ryglice, it is him. Also worth searching: New York arrivals from about 1885 to February 1888, before the blizzard.
Father’s side Who was Abraham and Jennie’s eighth child?
In the 1900 census Jennie is “mother of 7 children, 5 living”, and Lew came in 1902, so there were eight. William (1898) is one of the two who died; the other is unnamed. Nathan’s 1892 birth certificate counts “2 or 3” older children with 2 living, so this baby may have been born about 1891, by our inference. Openrecord More
Where to look next: NYC death indexes 1889–1900 for a Salander, Solender, Sollender or Selander child of Abraham and Jennie; the Washington Cemetery burial register (where William was buried); and the Adolph Ullman Aid Society’s burial records.
Father’s side Who were Yosef Solender’s and Yehuda Leib Scheps’s parents?
Ryglice’s Jewish registers from before 1877 have not been found, and the Tarnów books (read 1849–1900) do not hold the family.
Where to look next: A written enquiry to the Polish State Archive in Tarnów (a draft is ready and waiting for Yehuda’s OK). A Y-DNA test on a male Salander, compared with the Roth/Solender descendants from Ryglice.
Father’s side Was the Tarnów Juda Leib Scheps (d. 1898) Jennie’s father, and how did Jennie come to America?
Checked on 23 Oct 2026: no Juda Leib Scheps + Brandel Baum marriage or child is in the JRI-Poland index, and no ship list for Jennie turned up under 12 spellings, 1884–1891. The Tarnów Juda Leib had a sister, Sara Nisel (wife of Leib Brand), and four children with Golda Rozenblum, 1882–1894, so a first wife Brandel before about 1880 is still possible. A Lewis Scheps, son of Naftali, lived at 36 Columbia St in 1896, on Jennie’s street; whether he is kin is a guess. Open More
Checked on 23 Oct 2026 (night): neither Louis nor Sam Sheps has a New York marriage certificate. Louis’s 1939 death certificate names his father as Israel Schepps, so he was probably not Jennie’s brother. Probablerecord Sam (Alexander), 1862–1921, married in the old country; his death certificate says “Don’t know” for both parents, so he is still open. Openrecord Baby Berdie (d. 1904) was probably named for Louis’s mother Bertha, which weakens the “Brandel” link. Guess
Where to look next: Sam Sheps’s gravestone at Baron Hirsch Cemetery, Staten Island, whose Hebrew inscription may name his father; the 1904 death certificate of baby Berdie Sheps; the Hamburg emigrant lists 1886–89; and Castle Garden arrivals 1885–89.
Father’s side Who was the rav of Roś around 1900?
The known rabbis of Roś are R’ Shmuel (late 1700s), R’ Isser Spektor (early 1800s) and the last rav, R’ Eliezer Szubowski (born 1913). Nobody has been found for Jacob and Ida’s years, about 1880–1920. Openpublishedpublishedtestimony
Where to look next: the Wołkowysk yizkor book’s Roś chapter in full, rabbinic approbations (haskamos) signed “Ros”, and Russian Crown-rabbi lists for Wołkowysk district.
Father’s side Where was Jacob born: Roś or “Suwalk”?
His 1914 ship list seems to read “Suwalk” (or “Luwalk”) as his birthplace, but his own papers say Roś. Openrecordrecord
Where to look next: a sharper image of the full 1914 page (Ellis Island / FamilySearch), and his 1914 Declaration of Intention.
Father’s side Was Abraham Keller Jacob’s brother?
An Abraham Keller born 10 September 1897 in “Ross, Russia” registered for the draft in the Bronx in 1942 (contact: Yetta Keller); an Abraham Keller, 22, born Ross, came in from Canada via St. Albans, Vermont. Possibleindex
Where to look next: his Social Security application (it names his parents) and the St. Albans card itself, to see if his parents were Hersh Keller and Gussie Malsky.
Father’s side Who was Anna Rubinstein?
A young Anna Rubinstein, born about 1908 in Poland and in America from 1911, lived with Rose and Jack Jaffe in 1930. How she was related is unknown. Open
Where to look next: the 1930 census page itself, and any 1911 arrival of a Rubinstein mother with a small Anna.
Father’s side The Roś revision lists
JewishGen has Grodno province family lists (revision lists) and Polish business directories that could name Menashe Rubinstein and Tzvi Aryeh Keller in Roś. Open
Where to look next: JewishGen’s Belarus SIG and Grodno revision-list databases (free with a JewishGen login).
Father’s side Who filed the Pages of Testimony for the Polatszek family?
Necha is now confirmed as Ida’s sister by the 1920 passenger list. The Yad Vashem Pages for the Polatszek family of Roś give no maiden name, so the match to those Pages is still probable.
Where to look next: The submitters’ names and addresses on the Pages may lead to living cousins. Also the Wołkowysk and Roś yizkor books.
Father’s side Jacob Keller in Denver, 1909–13?
His 1914 passenger list notes an earlier stay in the US: “1909/13 Denver Col.”
Where to look next: Denver city directories 1909–13 and the 1910 census for Denver (Kaller/Keller/Koller), and an earlier arrival list for about 1909.
Mother’s side Who was Jacob Montrose’s first wife?
His 1914 Lusitania list names a wife left behind in Gomel, “Leike(?) Mondresow”. Nothing more is known about her.
Where to look next: Gomel metrical books (Mogilev province). The Hanshaft brother-in-law at 591–595 3rd Ave, Brooklyn, in the 1915 and 1920 censuses; he may be her brother.
Father’s side Jacob Keller’s death certificate (1949)
He died in Manhattan on 14 March 1949, certificate no. 5682. Confirmedindex The certificate itself, which would name his parents and give his last address, is not online: the city’s free images stop at 1948.
Where to look next: Order a copy from the NYC Municipal Archives (Manhattan, 1949, no. 5682). The archive warns that its 1949 film is in poor condition, so it is worth asking before ordering.
Father’s side More about Tzvi Aryeh Keller’s family
Jacob’s father, Tzvi Aryeh (Hirsch) Keller, and his wife Chaje “Gussie” Malsky had at least four children: Jacob (1881), Samuel (1884), Philip (1889) and Rose (Mrs. Simon Malsky). Their own dates and graves are unknown. One guess about when he died is on the Leads page.
Where to look next: Roś records in the JewishGen Belarus databases (they need a free login); Samuel’s 1946 death certificate (Bronx no. 4472), which may give his father’s name more carefully than the index; and a clearer photo of the Samuel Keller stone at Beth-El, Paramus.
Father’s side When did Rose and Jack Jaffe die?
Rosie’s married name is now found: she married Jack Jaffe in the Bronx on 25 December 1927. Confirmedrecord She was still in New York City in 1950 and had died by September 2003.
Where to look next: The Social Security Death Index and New York cemetery records under Jaffe; obituaries in New York papers.
Father’s side Where did Menashe Rubinstein learn?
Ida’s father, of Roś. His yeshiva or rebbe, and his dates, have not been found.
Where to look next: The Wołkowysk and Roś yizkor books, and the rabbinic lists of the Grodno region.
Father’s side Is there a photograph of Lew?
None has been found online.
Where to look next: The Rutland Historical Society, the Rutland Jewish Center’s albums, and the Rutland Herald’s 1996 obituary.
Father’s side Abraham’s death certificate (1962)
Not yet seen. His death on 6 November 1962 is in the city’s death index. Probableindex Answered, Oct 23: Morris, once “not found after 1915”, was Matthew Arthur Salander (1895–1940). More
Where to look next: NYC Department of Health (paid copy), and a New York Times death notice around 7–8 November 1962.
Mother’s side Jacob Montrose’s birth and Lazer’s line in Ukraine
Kharkiv metrical records of 1910–12 are attached to an online tree but have not been read here.
Where to look next: FamilySearch Ukraine Jewish metrical books (Kharkiv, Chernigov), and the Gomel archive.
Mother’s side Arthur Raskin’s home town
He was a tailor who came in 1905. His town is not known.
Where to look next: His naturalization papers (Chicago, 1920s–30s) and his WWI/WWII draft cards.
Update, 23 Oct: his 1915 citizenship papers say “Mansk, Russia” and his mother’s death record says “Musk, Russia”, so probably Minsk; Mińsk Mazowiecki is also possible. Probableindexindex Arthur on the People page
Mother’s side Lazer Mondrus’s gravestone in Sioux City
The stone’s photo is attached to FamilySearch but could not be downloaded.
Where to look next: Find a Grave and BillionGraves under “Laizer Montrose”. The Hebrew line should name his father.
Mother’s side Lazer Mondrus’s 1912 border crossing
An online tree says he came through Quebec on 4 July 1912. The record itself has not been read.
Where to look next: FamilySearch, “United States, Border Crossings from Canada, 1895–1956”, under Mondrus, Mondres and Fradin, 1912.